IGRCP vs WASK vs AppSorteos vs Simpliers: Which Instagram Comment Picker Fits Your Giveaway?

IGRCP vs WASK vs AppSorteos vs Simpliers: Which Instagram Comment Picker Fits Your Giveaway?

IGRCP vs WASK vs AppSorteos vs Simpliers: Which Instagram Comment Picker Fits Your Giveaway?

At first glance, every Instagram comment picker does the same thing. Paste a post link, load the comments, press a button, and someone wins.

Then the details arrive. Did it load all 12,000 comments or stop after the first page? Does the free plan cover your giveaway or only the first 300 entries? Are you buying a tool once or subscribing to it forever? And when a follower comments "rigged", can you show them anything more than a screenshot?

We compared four popular options — IGRCP, WASK, AppSorteos and Simpliers — on the things that change your draw: price model, comment limits, filters, exports, proof and account requirements.

Full disclosure: IGRCP is our tool. We have tried to keep this comparison factual and fair, including the places where a competitor is the better choice. Prices and limits were checked on 21 November 2026. They change, so confirm on each site before you buy.

This is a comparison of published features and pricing, not a timed lab test. Where a vendor does not publish a limit, we say so rather than guess. Where our own test differed from the landing page, we say that too.

The short version

  • IGRCP is the one-off option. No account, no subscription, Instagram only. Good for occasional giveaways, CSV exports and a verifiable proof page for every draw. The free tier is 50 comments, tied with WASK for the smallest free allowance of the four.
  • WASK is the no-frills option with a 50-comment free tier. Paste, scan, pick. It is the simplest way to draw a winner, but it has fewer filters, no export or certificate advertised, and its paid plans are monthly.
  • AppSorteos is the multi-network suite. Giveaways on eight platforms, branded winner animations, certificates and promotion tools. Subscription pricing, and Instagram may require a professional account.
  • Simpliers is the high-volume rule-keeper. Every comment, follow checks, AI-filled rules, certificates and a mobile app. The free tier is 200 entries; volume is subscription-based.

The four tools at a glance

IGRCP

  • Free: 50 comments per post
  • Paid: £3.49 for 1,000 comments, £5.49 for 5,000, £9.99 for larger posts plus £1 per additional 1,000
  • Account: none
  • Best at: cheap one-off draws, no login, CSV export, a public proof page for every winner
  • Watch out: 50-comment free allowance, tied with WASK for the smallest of the four; Instagram only; no follow verification

WASK

  • Free: 50 comments per draw
  • Paid: $9/month for under 1,000 comments, $15 for under 5,000, $25 for under 10,000 and $45 for unlimited (introductory prices at the time of writing)
  • Account: the landing page advertises no login, but in our test the paid tiers appeared only after creating an account
  • Best at: a quick, simple draw with minimal setup
  • Watch out: the free tier stops at 50 comments, pricing is hidden until signup, basic filters, no CSV export or validity certificate advertised

AppSorteos

  • Free: 300 comments per post
  • Paid: about $9/month for 2,000 comments, $19/month for 5,000, $49/month for unlimited
  • Account: no signup for URL draws, but Instagram may ask you to connect a professional account
  • Best at: multi-network giveaways, branded animations, certificates and promotions
  • Watch out: subscription pricing, professional-account friction, export limits below the comment limit

Simpliers

  • Free: 200 entries, first giveaway per post
  • Paid: $19.90/month for up to 40,000 entries, or $9.99/month on annual billing ($119.90/year)
  • Account: none
  • Best at: high-volume draws, strict rules, follow checks, certificates, mobile app
  • Watch out: subscription for volume; the free tier is a trial

Price: the difference between a one-off and a subscription

The biggest difference is not the sticker price. It is the shape of the price.

IGRCP sells one-off unlocks. You pay for the comments you need, once, and the post stays unlocked. WASK sells monthly picker plans alongside its ad-management platform. AppSorteos and Simpliers sell monthly subscriptions, with annual discounts.

WASK deserves a note of its own. Its landing page advertises a completely free picker with no login. In our test, the free draw stopped at 50 comments, and the paid tiers appeared only after creating an account.

The plans are billed monthly:

$9 for under 1,000 comments,

$15 for under 5,000,

$25 for under 10,000 and

$45 for unlimited at the time of writing.

That is a 50-comment trial, not an unlimited free tool. The three-step flow is clean and WASK is an Instagram Partner, but the gap between the landing page and the checkout is worth knowing about.

Here is what one 5,000-comment giveaway costs at the published rates:

  • IGRCP: £5.49 once
  • WASK: $25 for one month (the $15 tier is for posts under 5,000 comments)
  • AppSorteos: about $19 for one month of Creator, which covers 5,000 comments
  • Simpliers: $19.90 for one month, which covers up to 40,000 entries

IGRCP prices are in GBP and the others are in USD, so the exact gap depends on the exchange rate. The difference in structure is the bigger point.

If you run three 5,000-comment giveaways a year, the gap widens:

  • IGRCP: £16.47
  • WASK: $75 if you pay for three separate months
  • AppSorteos: about $57 if you pay monthly and cancel each time
  • Simpliers: about $59.70 monthly, or $119.90 upfront on the annual plan

WASK's $45 unlimited tier is better value if you run several large giveaways within one billing month. For occasional draws, the one-off unlock is still cheaper.

Subscriptions also renew unless you cancel. WASK, AppSorteos and Simpliers are monthly plans; IGRCP is a one-off unlock. AppSorteos' FAQ says its subscription payments are non-refundable, so a forgotten renewal is an expensive mistake.

None of this makes subscriptions bad value. If you run giveaways every week, need multi-platform entries, follow checks and certificates, a monthly plan can be the cheaper way to get all of that. The point is to pay for the model that matches your frequency.

And free is only a bargain if it does the job. WASK's free tier stops at 50 comments, so for most real giveaways you are comparing paid tools anyway.

Comment limits: how many entries can you actually draw from?

Instagram returns comments in pages. A picker can only choose from the comments it has loaded. If it stops after the first page, everyone after that is invisible.

That is the old "last 150 comments" problem, and it is worth checking before every giveaway. On a 5,000-comment post, 150 comments is 3% of your entries. The winner might be perfectly random and still be drawn from the wrong pool.

How the four compare:

  • IGRCP: 50 comments free; 1,000 or 5,000 on a one-off unlock; all comments on the unlocked post, with replies included on paid unlocks. Loads at around 60 comments per second through a distributed network.
  • WASK: 50 comments free; paid tiers for under 1,000, under 5,000, under 10,000 and unlimited comments. The tool scans the post and picks from the comments it finds.
  • AppSorteos: 300 comments free, 2,000 on Starter, 5,000 on Creator and unlimited on Agency. Limits apply per post, not per month.
  • Simpliers: 200 entries free, up to 40,000 entries on the monthly plan. It fetches every comment page by page, which is thorough but can take time on very large posts.

For a first giveaway with 150 comments, Simpliers' 200-entry free tier or AppSorteos' 300 will take you further than the 50-comment free tiers from IGRCP and WASK. For a 5,000-comment post, IGRCP's £5.49 is the cheapest paid route; WASK, Simpliers and AppSorteos cost more, but include the wider platform.

Speed depends on Instagram, your connection and the post. Treat every vendor's number as a best case. IGRCP's 60-per-second figure means a 10,000-comment post is roughly three minutes of loading. Simpliers explains that it walks Instagram's pages one by one, so the wait grows with the comment count. AppSorteos shows an estimated time before it starts.

Filters: can the tool enforce your giveaway rules?

A random draw is only fair if the entries are valid. This is where the tools separate.

IGRCP filters by keyword, minimum mentions, duplicates and bad words. You can add extra entries per mention, and include or exclude your own comments. That covers the common "tag a friend and comment your favourite colour" giveaway. It does not check whether a winner follows you.

WASK offers basic criteria around the draw. It is built for speed, not for a long rulebook.

AppSorteos handles mentions, hashtags, duplicate comments and a block list. You can pick multiple winners, include promoted posts, and choose a winner animation. It covers most brand giveaways without needing a spreadsheet.

Simpliers has the deepest rule set: minimum tag count, word filters, count-everyone-once, a fair participation limit, follow checks, minimum post count and minimum follower count. It can also fill your rules with AI from the caption, and it offers substitutes if a winner does not meet the requirements.

If your rules are one line, IGRCP or WASK is enough. If a sponsor writes the rules and asks you to verify followers, Simpliers is the safer choice. AppSorteos sits in the middle.

Proof: certificate, screenshot or hash?

Sooner or later, someone says the draw was rigged. What can you show them?

IGRCP publishes a proof page for every draw. It shows the winner, the number of eligible comments, the entry list as a downloadable JSON file, a SHA-256 hash of that list and the seed used for the draw. The page also explains how to recompute the result. You get a winner card and a story-sized card for sharing. It is not a decorative certificate, but it is independently checkable.

Simpliers generates a public certificate and results page with a giveaway code. Followers can check the result, and you can live-stream the draw or download a story video. This is the strongest audience-facing proof of the four.

AppSorteos offers a public certificate link, image and video certificates, and branded winner animations. It is the most polished option if the draw is part of a brand campaign.

WASK relies on screenshots or a screen recording. That is fine for a casual giveaway. It is weaker if a sponsor asks for a verifiable record.

Which one matters depends on your audience. A screen recording is usually enough for a creator giveaway. A public proof page or certificate saves arguments when real money or brand reputation is involved.

Exports: can you take the comment list with you?

An export is useful for sponsor reports, audits, re-draws, block lists and next month's content ideas.

  • IGRCP: CSV export on paid unlocks, including every loaded comment.
  • AppSorteos: export limits depend on plan: 100 comments free, 500 on Starter, 3,000 on Creator and 10,000 on Agency. Note that Creator allows 5,000 comments per draw but only 3,000 exports.
  • Simpliers: XLS export on paid plans.
  • WASK: no export advertised on the picker page.

If the sponsor wants the full comment list as a spreadsheet, check the export cap before you pay. A plan that loads 5,000 comments may not let you download all 5,000.

Accounts and privacy: who needs a login?

All four can start from a public post URL. None needs your Instagram password to read a public post.

  • IGRCP: no account at all. Paste a link and draw.
  • WASK: the landing page says no login or signup, but in our test the pricing appeared only after creating an account.
  • AppSorteos: no signup for a URL draw, but its FAQ says Instagram only exposes comments for professional accounts, so some posts will ask you to connect Instagram or switch account type.
  • Simpliers: no account needed to run a giveaway.

The general rule: never give a giveaway tool your Instagram password. A public URL is enough. If a tool asks you to connect Instagram, it is usually requesting API access for a business or creator account. Decide whether that permission is worth the convenience.

Platforms and extras: when Instagram is not the whole campaign

IGRCP is Instagram only. It also has an AI post-analysis tool for reading comment threads and a set of free decision tools, but it will not pick winners from TikTok or YouTube.

WASK covers Instagram, Facebook, X, YouTube, TikTok and Reddit, and sells monthly picker plans alongside its ad-management platform.

AppSorteos covers Instagram, Facebook, X, YouTube, TikTok, LinkedIn, Twitch and Bluesky. It also offers spin-the-wheel promotions, scratch cards, trivia and a giveaway directory.

Simpliers covers Instagram, Facebook, X and YouTube, with multi-post draws, DM automations, a giveaway post creator, trends and a mobile app.

If your campaign runs across several platforms, IGRCP is the wrong shape. If you only need Instagram, you may be paying for features you will never use with the suites.

A 5,000-comment giveaway, side by side

Imagine a launch post with 5,000 comments, three winners, duplicates removed, a CSV for the sponsor and a proof link for the caption.

  • IGRCP: £5.49. Load the post, filter duplicates, draw a winner, draw again for the next two (each winner is removed from the pool), export the CSV and share the proof page. Total: £5.49.
  • WASK: $25 for one month (the $15 tier is for posts under 5,000 comments). Scan the post, apply basic criteria, pick a winner and screenshot it. No CSV or certificate. Total: $25.
  • AppSorteos: about $19 for one month of Creator. Filters, three winners, certificate and animations. The Creator plan exports 3,000 comments, so a full 5,000-row CSV needs Agency at about $49 for the month. Total: $19–$49.
  • Simpliers: $19.90 for one month. All comments, follow checks, three winners plus substitutes, certificate, results page and XLS export. Total: $19.90.

Same post. Same comments. Very different bills, and very different amounts of proof.

Who should choose which tool?

Choose IGRCP if...

  • You run one giveaway at a time and do not want another subscription.
  • You want no account and no Instagram login.
  • You need a CSV and useful filters without a full marketing suite.
  • You are using a personal account and do not want to convert it.
  • You want a verifiable proof page for every draw.
  • You do not need multi-platform entries or follow verification.

Choose WASK if...

  • You want a simple draw and 50 comments is enough, or you do not mind a monthly plan.
  • One winner and basic criteria are enough.
  • You do not need an export or a certificate.
  • You already use WASK for ads.

Choose AppSorteos if...

  • You run giveaways across several social networks.
  • You want branded winner animations and certificates.
  • You run promotions, spin-the-wheel campaigns or a giveaway directory.
  • You have a professional Instagram account and do not mind a subscription.

Choose Simpliers if...

  • You need to load tens of thousands of comments.
  • Your rules include follow checks, minimum tags or a participation limit.
  • You want a public certificate, results page and giveaway code.
  • You run giveaways often enough to justify a monthly plan.
  • You want a mobile app or DM automations alongside the draw.

The honest limits of IGRCP

IGRCP is our tool, so here is the other side of the comparison:

  • It only works with Instagram. No TikTok, YouTube or multi-network draws.
  • The free tier is 50 comments, tied with WASK for the smallest free allowance. It is a test drive, not a full giveaway.
  • It does not verify that a winner follows you. If a sponsor requires follow checks, use Simpliers or AppSorteos.
  • It does not generate a branded certificate. It generates a public proof page with the entry list, hash and seed, plus winner cards for sharing.
  • It works with public posts only. Private accounts and disabled comments cannot be read.
  • Paid unlocks are per post. If you run many posts, the costs add up, even if each one is small.

If those limits do not affect your giveaway, the one-off price is hard to beat. If they do, one of the subscriptions is the better tool.

FAQ

Is IGRCP free?

Yes, for up to 50 comments per post. Paid unlocks are one-off: £3.49 for 1,000 comments, £5.49 for 5,000, and £9.99 for larger posts plus £1 per additional 1,000. There is no subscription.

Do I need to log in with Instagram?

No. Paste a public post, Reel or IGTV link. IGRCP never asks for your Instagram password.

Can I pick more than one winner?

Yes. Each draw removes the winner from the eligible pool, so you can draw again for runners-up without duplicates.

Does IGRCP work with personal accounts?

Yes, for public posts, Reels and IGTV. Some competitors require a business or creator account; IGRCP does not.

Which tool is cheapest for 5,000 comments?

IGRCP is £5.49 one-off. WASK is $25/month for a 5,000-comment post (or $15 if the post is under 5,000). AppSorteos is about $19/month for 5,000 comments, but its Creator plan exports only 3,000. Simpliers is $19.90/month for up to 40,000 entries. Check current prices before you buy.

Which tool is best for proving a draw was fair?

Simpliers and AppSorteos offer branded certificates and public results pages. IGRCP publishes a public proof page with the entry list, SHA-256 hash and seed. WASK relies on screenshots or a screen recording.

Can I export the comments?

IGRCP exports CSV on paid unlocks. AppSorteos exports 100 to 10,000 comments depending on plan. Simpliers exports XLS on paid plans. WASK does not advertise an export.

Do these tools work with private Instagram accounts?

Not reliably. The URL-based workflow needs public posts with comments enabled. Simpliers suggests switching the account to public for the giveaway and back afterwards.

Are the prices in this post current?

They were checked on 21 November 2026. Prices and limits change, so confirm on each provider's site before you pay.

The bottom line

Pick the tool for the draw you are actually running.

If you want a simple draw and only need 50 comments, WASK's free tier works. Beyond that, its monthly plans cost more than a one-off IGRCP unlock for an occasional giveaway. If you want a full multi-platform suite with certificates and branded animations, AppSorteos or Simpliers earn their subscriptions. If you want a one-off Instagram draw with no account, a CSV, useful filters and a proof page you can share, IGRCP is built for exactly that.

Paste a public post, load the comments and crown a winner. The first 50 comments are free.

Try the Instagram comment picker →